Good Areas

Good Areas

Share this post

Good Areas
Good Areas
PNG's incredible village
Copy link
Facebook
Email
Notes
More
User's avatar
Discover more from Good Areas
In cricket's footmarks.
Over 7,000 subscribers
Already have an account? Sign in

PNG's incredible village

Plus notes on Scotland's amazing win over Bangladesh

Jarrod Kimber's avatar
Jarrod Kimber
Oct 17, 2021

Share this post

Good Areas
Good Areas
PNG's incredible village
Copy link
Facebook
Email
Notes
More
Share

The World Cup has started. And that means the latest nation has joined, Papua New Guinea.

PNG caught fire as a team at a perfect time. They weren't considered a lock for this World Cup, but they played an incredible form of cricket in the qualifiers. They are a magic team to watch. 

They combine incredible flair with some incredibly textbook cricket. Like for example, Simon Atai was at the non-striker's end during their disastrous three-wicket over. He was backing up as far as you can with his bat in the crease, squatting ready to sprint, but also making sure he couldn't be mankadded; it was like a perfect coaching manual. 

Twitter avatar for @ajarrodkimber
Jarrod Kimber @ajarrodkimber
Been watching the PNG team for a couple of weeks, not sure I’ve ever seen a closer team. They are a family who just qualified for the World Cup. Cricket wins again.
3:49 PM ∙ Oct 27, 2019
368Likes36Retweets

You will hear them being referred to as a family a lot. And compared to other cricket teams they certainly feel more like a family than a collection of athletes. In Dubai for the qualifiers, I have never seen a team travel around together so closely.  

When you get to the top level of professional sports, you find that not everyone enjoys the sport they are good at. At that level people are often there because they are physically gifted and they follow the money. Below that, it's mostly because people love the game. It's clear this is a team of cricket lovers. 

PNG wear proper cricket caps on the field. Like the sort you'd see on first class cricketers around the world. They are a new team but old at heart. 

Twitter avatar for @ajarrodkimber
Jarrod Kimber @ajarrodkimber
Hell of a trivia question “which team’s first run in a World Cup was from their number four?”
10:12 AM ∙ Oct 17, 2021
257Likes11Retweets

But they're good too, this game was not a perfect example of that. When you start off by having your number four scoring your first ever World Cup run, it's a horrible way to begin. 

Ofcourse they came back, in part through Charles CJ Amini. And it's worth focusing on Amini. He is a top-quality lefty batter, you could see from his innings not only his skill, but the way he thinks through the knock. As a number four, he's been a slow scorer, but over the last few years he's taken a big step forward. And when he was at the crease was the only time PNG were ahead of the match.  

He can bowl legspin too, averaging 22 with a 6.3 Econ as well. He's not a spectacular leggie, but he's good. Accurate and clever, always trying to work you out. He would walk into this team with either bat or ball. 

And as good as he is for these skills. He's a better fielder. He's probably one of the best ten - or at least 20 - fielders in the world. The TV commentators almost completely ignored the PNG new ball bowlers - who struggled a little - to focus on Amini's fielding. 

The entire team is good. Their team nickname is the Barramundi, which I have always thought is the tastiest fish. Well, their fielding is almost that good.  

In Dubai, I would watch their fielding training. I mean, that's Colin Bland level fielding. They were all throwing at a stump from a distance of 25-30 metres, and they hit it so many times that it was pointless doing the drill. They'd have been better off having a laser stump, as they had to stop so often to reset it.

Even in this loss to Oman, as their batting was two guys, and their bowling was ropey, they still looked incredible in the field (although they dropped one sitter). In associate cricket, people are terrified of their ring skills. Preston Mommsen said on commentary he thinks they are worth 10-20 runs in the field. And I would honestly watch Kipling Doriga wicket keep on a supercut for hours. But Amini is something else. 

A few years back, I met Amini and asked who his agent was because I assumed he was like a T20 franchise player grown in a lab. But he didn't have one, he was shocked that I thought he should be on the T20 circuit.  

But none of that is even the most amazing thing about him. This is a new team, but with a long history in the game. And the Amini family more so than others. There is even a ground in PNG called Amini park. 

That is because Amini's grandfather, father, mother, aunty and brother all played cricket for PNG. This is a cricket family, inside a cricket nation that most of us never even knew we had.  

Twitter avatar for @NickFriend1
Nick Friend @NickFriend1
I am entirely here for Charles Amini. Mother, father, brother and grandfather all played for Papua New Guinea, the national stadium - Amini Park - is named after the family. But he's the first to reach a World Cup. Just a lovely story within a beautiful rise.
10:32 AM ∙ Oct 17, 2021
220Likes34Retweets

And the family thing runs deep. Today their top scorer was Assad Vala, and both he and his wife have played for PNG.  

Vala is one of the few players in this team not from Hanuabada Village, just near Port Moresby. Hanuabada means big (or biggest) village. A remarkable cricket-loving space that most fans don't know exists. 

Thanks to the English scene, village cricket is a negative phrase. "That's so village". 

But this team has taken the love from that one little place, and turned it into a World Cup, they field like one living organism, and they love this sport. Their sport. 

When village is said about PNG, it's not a slur, but a badge of honour. Now PNG are a World Cup cricket team, they started poorly, and finished worse, but they are here. They are a family and cricket's biggest village team. 

Share


Twitter avatar for @ajarrodkimber
Jarrod Kimber @ajarrodkimber
What a moment for Oman. Host the start of the tournament. And absolutely smash PNG off the park. And what a ground. Incredible to think that this team was playing on concrete wickets a decade back.
12:58 PM ∙ Oct 17, 2021
253Likes15Retweets

Notes on Bangladesh v Scotland 

Twitter avatar for @ajarrodkimber
Jarrod Kimber @ajarrodkimber
This is a low-key one way grudge match. Scottish cricket still hasn’t gotten over the fact that Bangladesh beat them in ‘99 WC and leapfrogged them in Test queue so quickly. The Gavin Hamilton run out is still upsetting to many.
2:08 PM ∙ Oct 17, 2021
389Likes33Retweets

Scotland are much better players of spin than this match showed. I saw a lot of people online saying they should use their feet more, but sweeping is their thing. If anything, I thought they got themselves in a bit of a hole at the top when Coetzer and Cross got stuck. 7 runs from 18 balls from two of your top three is hard to overcome. 

Scotland had Tom Sole batting around number seven for the qualifiers, being a gun in the field and bowling some Johan Botha style offspin. Sadly, he got called for an illegal action in that series and he's a difficult player to cover. And so at the last minute for this tournament, Scotland went with Chris Greaves. Who is a leg-spinning all rounder, who can field. To say he hasn't played much before would be an understatement. 

Twitter avatar for @ajarrodkimber
Jarrod Kimber @ajarrodkimber
Chris Greaves is playing his eighth pro match, he's 31. So far he's made 50 professional runs. He's largely in the side to bowl. Below are his last few games according to @ESPNcricinfo The 27* against Ireland A was from 20 balls. And in his first WC match he's made 45 from 28
Image
3:44 PM ∙ Oct 17, 2021
175Likes16Retweets
Twitter avatar for @aadamp9
Aadam @aadamp9
Kyle Coetzer on Chris Greaves: “He was delivering parcels for Amazon not long ago, and now he's out here getting MOTM against Bangladesh. I'm not sure he'll appreciate me saying that, but there's a lot of sacrifices from him. We’re all extremely proud of him.”
8:04 PM ∙ Oct 17, 2021
143Likes33Retweets

What a remarkable effort for what is really a club cricketer who has played some A cricket with Scotland and the odd second XI match in county cricket. He overcame the Scotland collapse and gave them a chance. 

Quick shout out for Mark Watt as well. He was let go by Derbyshire a couple of years back, and it seemed like a mistake then, and now. He's such a clever cricketer. You could see that in his batting, partnering up with Greaves. But also his bowling. He really doesn't spin it much at all, but changes every ball through crease positioning and pace. Against left-handers he sometimes bowls wrist spin when needed. And this:

Twitter avatar for @mroller98
Matt Roller @mroller98
The old Robert Croft/Kieron Pollard 24-yarder there from Mark Watt - delivered from a good couple of paces behind the back crease
4:49 PM ∙ Oct 17, 2021
35Likes1Retweet

He's so smart and thinks like a spoiler every delivery, and because he is strong, people find him difficult to get away.

It's a first outing from Bangladesh, and it was hard to tell if they were just trying to shake some rust off, or if they thought they had Scotland gone a couple of times so geared back. They were - rightfully - surprised by Greaves. And they also wouldn't have planned much for Watt. But even so, they allowed Scotland to put on way too many runs from 57/6.

Share

What was Shakib's innings? The chase got to nine an over, and he still never woke up. He was unlucky to be dismissed from a half-tracker, but after Bangladesh had lost two early wickets, their slow down was way over the top. They needed seven an over, allowing it to be nine an over by the eighth is such a bizarre way to make this chase. 

I never felt the chase was away from Bangladesh until very late , but I can't really understand how they allowed it to balloon so many times. Bangladesh's top order is a concern, with or without Tamim Iqbal. 

Twitter avatar for @ajarrodkimber
Jarrod Kimber @ajarrodkimber
Really hope that Gavin Hamilton and all the past Scotland players are smiling tonight. Kind of fitting that Greaves played such a big part in this too, as Scotland have always had such a strong club cricket culture.
5:59 PM ∙ Oct 17, 2021
157Likes10Retweets

This is a remarkable win for Scotland. This is their first great win in a world cup. And I don't think we've ever had a team with this long and proud a cricket community whose had to wait this long for their first World Cup win. 


Twitter avatar for @ajarrodkimber
Jarrod Kimber @ajarrodkimber
Latest Wagon Wheel on T20 batting, captaincy and weird playing conditions
anchor.fmThe Wagon Wheel on Spotify Greenroom - 15-10-21 by Red Inker With Jarrod KimberThis week on Wagon Wheel, Jarrod answers questions from our loveable Patreon sponsors, and questions from our attendees on cricket league point scoring, associate team makeup, the juggle of AB and Maxwell for RCB, T20 rules in Australia, and the legacy of Dhoni’s captaincy. - Each week, Jarrod Kimbe…
10:20 AM ∙ Oct 17, 2021
Twitter avatar for @ajarrodkimber
Jarrod Kimber @ajarrodkimber
Latest Red Inker is Mike Jakeman on the rise of CricViz and the birth of analytics in cricket
anchor.fmThe Birth Of Cricketball with Mike Jakeman by Red Inker With Jarrod KimberThis episode we talk about the boom of cricket analysis by discussing the history of CricViz and to do so we got on a journalist who has just written about them, Mike Jakeman. We talk about legendary statistician Charles Davis, Hawkeye, TV, working for teams, Krishna Tunga and we look at some of the…
8:20 AM ∙ Oct 17, 2021
7Likes2Retweets

Subscribe to Good Areas

Hundreds of paid subscribers
In cricket's footmarks.

Share this post

Good Areas
Good Areas
PNG's incredible village
Copy link
Facebook
Email
Notes
More
Share

Discussion about this post

User's avatar
How two new balls changed ODI cricket
In October 2011, cricket changed how many new balls it uses in ODI cricket. So we looked into what actually changed.
Sep 14, 2023 • 
Jarrod Kimber
7

Share this post

Good Areas
Good Areas
How two new balls changed ODI cricket
Copy link
Facebook
Email
Notes
More
Virat Kohli was flawless
Batsmen make errors, but for this knock, Kohli was at war with mistakes.
Feb 9, 2021 • 
Jarrod Kimber
15

Share this post

Good Areas
Good Areas
Virat Kohli was flawless
Copy link
Facebook
Email
Notes
More
6
The bias against spinning pitches
A look at many of the reasons that we react as we do when a pitch spins on day one.
Feb 14, 2021 • 
Jarrod Kimber
21

Share this post

Good Areas
Good Areas
The bias against spinning pitches
Copy link
Facebook
Email
Notes
More
16

Ready for more?

© 2025 Jarrod Kimber
Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start writingGet the app
Substack is the home for great culture

Share

Copy link
Facebook
Email
Notes
More

Create your profile

User's avatar

Only paid subscribers can comment on this post

Already a paid subscriber? Sign in

Check your email

For your security, we need to re-authenticate you.

Click the link we sent to , or click here to sign in.